News21 Nov 2026KalshiCFTCNew YorkLetitia JamesGambling LawCommodity Exchange Act
Judge rejects CFTC emergency bid to halt New York’s Kalshi case
The ruling leaves New York free to pursue its gambling-law claims while courts remain divided over federal oversight of prediction markets.
A federal judge in Manhattan rejected the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s emergency bid to stop New York Attorney General Letitia James from pursuing her enforcement case against prediction-market operator Kalshi, allowing the state action to proceed.
U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield ruled Nov. 20 that the CFTC had “not established a likelihood of success on the merits” of its claim that federal commodities law pre-empts state gambling-law enforcement against prediction-market operators. The decision addressed a request for immediate relief rather than finally resolving the underlying federal-state jurisdiction dispute.
The CFTC moved after U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick sent New York’s lawsuit against Kalshi back to Manhattan state court the previous day. The agency argued that the transfer left “no practical barrier to New York moving full steam ahead” against the company.
As we reported on Nov. 20, Kalshi had separately asked the Manhattan state court to prevent any renewed temporary restraining order without first giving the company a hearing.
James alleges that Kalshi has run an unlicensed gambling operation in New York and should have obtained a New York State Gaming Commission licence. The state seeks to bar Kalshi from operating an unlicensed gambling business, as well as accounting, restitution, disgorgement, damages, penalties and costs.
New York’s petition says gambling is unlawful in the state except in limited licensed categories, and that the Gaming Commission has general jurisdiction over gaming, including sports wagering. The commission issued Kalshi a cease-and-desist demand in October 2025 concerning its unlicensed mobile sports-wagering platform. Kalshi sued the commission three days later, and the commission agreed to hold off enforcement while the company’s injunction request was pending.
Kalshi, which received CFTC designation as a contract market in November 2020, began listing self-certified sports-event contracts in January 2025. Its contracts allow users to take positions on sporting outcomes and receive payment if their chosen outcome occurs. The company has also offered markets involving elections and other events.
The CFTC contends that such event contracts are derivatives, including swaps, traded on federally regulated exchanges. Its April complaint argued that the Commodity Exchange Act grants the agency exclusive jurisdiction over commodity futures, options and swaps on those exchanges, and that New York’s gambling-law case is therefore pre-empted. The agency has sued 12 states in support of that claimed authority.
Schofield noted the conflicting court decisions. Federal courts have reached different preliminary conclusions on whether state gambling laws apply to Kalshi’s sports contracts: Judge Analisa Torres denied Kalshi preliminary relief against New York in July, finding that the Commodity Exchange Act did not pre-empt the state laws for that purpose, while the Third Circuit held in April that Kalshi had shown a reasonable chance of success on its pre-emption argument against New Jersey.
The Third Circuit characterized the contracts at issue as swaps on a CFTC-licensed designated contract market and found New Jersey’s laws pre-empted at that stage. Schofield said three federal appeals courts had allowed states to regulate Kalshi, while a fourth had ruled for Kalshi in New Jersey, leaving a split that could ultimately require Supreme Court review.
The dispute has broadened beyond the litigation. On Nov. 20, a bipartisan coalition of 44 attorneys general opposed CFTC rulemakings that they said could place sports and election betting on prediction markets solely under federal oversight. New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport said the proposals would displace states’ longstanding role in regulating gambling.
New York has nine licensed mobile sports-wagering operators. They generated about $2 billion in gross gaming revenue and paid more than $1 billion in state taxes in 2024, according to the Attorney General’s petition.
Sources
Earlier coverage
- Kalshi seeks to block New York order it says could halt trading nationwide
- Second Circuit declines to shield Kalshi and Coinbase from New York and Connecticut cases
- New York judge weighs whether federal law shields prediction markets from state gambling rules
- CFTC seeks emergency order to halt Utah’s Kalshi enforcement
- Second Circuit leaves Kalshi’s New York and Connecticut losses in place
Researched and written by Cite, an automated research pipeline. Sources are linked above.