News20 Nov 2026KalshiNew YorkLetitia JamesCFTCSports BettingGambling Law
Kalshi seeks to block New York order it says could halt trading nationwide
The prediction-market operator wants a hearing before New York renews a restraining-order request after its case was sent back to state court.
Kalshi has asked Manhattan Supreme Court to refuse any renewed temporary restraining order sought without hearing the company first, after a federal judge returned New York Attorney General Letitia James’s enforcement case to state court. The prediction-market operator said the proposed restrictions could halt trading beyond New York and force the liquidation of open positions.
The request seeks an immediate status conference and a chance to respond before the court considers an ex parte application. Kalshi argued that New York had shown no emergency requiring an order without notice, noting that the company began operating in 2021, introduced sports-event contracts in January 2025, and faced a state cease-and-desist notice in October 2025.
Judge Vernon S. Broderick granted New York’s motion to remand on Nov. 19, finding that the federal court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction. He ruled that the federal-officer removal statute did not give Kalshi a path into federal court, and that federal commodities rules may allow designated contract markets to offer event contracts but do not guarantee a right to offer them in New York. The judge declined to award New York attorneys’ fees, finding that Kalshi had reasonable grounds to remove the case.
The state’s original restraining-order request became moot during the federal proceedings, but James may renew it following remand. The proposed terms cover contracts involving “sports, culture, elections, and other events” offered within or from New York, or to New Yorkers.
Kalshi, which is headquartered in New York, contends that this language could prevent it from serving customers elsewhere in the United States. It said the undefined reference to other events could reach financial-market and economic-indicator contracts, rather than solely sports-related products. The company cited annualized trading volume of $178 billion and a $22 billion valuation in describing the potential impact.
The company also argued that a state shutdown order would conflict with an emergency CFTC directive requiring it to maintain exchange operations under federal market requirements. The CFTC characterized New York’s action as a “major market disturbance” and warned that an unexpected shutdown of a federally regulated exchange could pose an “existential threat” to participants and its own regulatory jurisdiction.
New York maintains that Kalshi’s federal registration does not displace state rules on licensing, taxation and consumer protection. Its July 31 petition alleges that the platform is an unlicensed gambling operation, including because it permits users aged 18 to 20 even though New York mobile sports wagering requires participants to be at least 21. The state seeks to stop the alleged activity, as well as restitution, forfeiture of alleged unlawful gains, civil penalties and costs.
Kalshi is a CFTC-designated contract market whose users trade yes-or-no contracts on whether events occur. Its earlier bid to block New York gambling-law enforcement against its sports contracts was denied by Judge Analisa Torres on July 7, and an injunction pending appeal was denied on July 27. That appeal remains pending in the Second Circuit.
Sources
Earlier coverage
- Kalshi sues Louisiana to block enforcement of sports-event contracts
- New Jersey asks Supreme Court to decide who regulates Kalshi sports contracts
- Kalshi seeks more time to answer New Jersey at Supreme Court
- Kalshi sues Missouri over sports-event contract crackdown
- New York Gaming Commission seeks court order over Kalshi subpoenas
Researched and written by Cite, an automated research pipeline. Sources are linked above.