News21 Nov 2026New JerseyCFTCSports BettingGambling Law
New Jersey co-leads 44-attorney-general challenge to CFTC prediction-market rules
The states say the agency’s treatment of peer-to-peer sports and election bets as swaps would displace state gambling safeguards.
New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport co-led a bipartisan coalition of 44 attorneys general in opposing two Commodity Futures Trading Commission rulemakings that the states say would move sports wagering, election betting and other prediction-market products into exclusive federal oversight.
The New Jersey Department of Law and Public Safety announced the coalition’s position Nov. 20. It argued that the measures would override the states’ longstanding authority over gambling and allow prediction-market operators to avoid state gambling laws and responsible-gaming safeguards.
One disputed measure is an interim rule already in force. It excludes only house-backed, casino-style games from the definition of swaps, meaning wagering between participants is treated differently. The second, still-proposed rule would explicitly classify peer-to-peer sports and election betting as swaps, placing them under CFTC regulation.
Davenport said the commission was straying beyond its remit by seeking to “exclusively regulate certain forms of sports gambling on prediction markets.” The coalition maintains that state gambling oversight covers more than casino games, including markets in which bettors take opposing positions.
The attorneys general contend that gambling regulation and protection from associated harms have traditionally been state responsibilities. They argue that the CFTC lacks power to address those harms, exceeded the authority Congress gave it and did not follow required rulemaking procedures.
A multistate comment letter also calls the interim rule arbitrary, capricious and procedurally defective. It says the agency lacked good cause for the interim approach, may not have had the required quorum and failed to issue the rule jointly with the Securities and Exchange Commission after consulting other required agencies.
The disagreement centers on products offered by platforms including Kalshi and Polymarket, which allow wagers on game results, point spreads and player statistics. The companies contend that, as CFTC-regulated contract markets, they are exempt from state gambling regulation.
The CFTC’s traditional jurisdiction includes financial contracts tied to commodities such as oil and wheat, interest rates and foreign currency. Its proposed prediction-market rules arrive as the agency says trading volume across CFTC-registered prediction markets exceeded $25 billion in 2025.
The regulatory clash also overlaps with New Jersey’s Supreme Court challenge to Kalshi. The state’s request for review has support from 39 states, the District of Columbia and 146 tribal nations and tribal organizations; New Jersey says most federal courts that have considered the question have rejected the view that sports-betting prediction markets are exempt from state law.
Sources
Earlier coverage
- 39 states and DC back New Jersey’s Supreme Court challenge to Kalshi
- Ohio-led coalition asks CFTC to abandon sports-contract swap rule
- New Jersey asks Supreme Court to decide who regulates Kalshi sports contracts
- NFL asks Supreme Court to let states regulate sports prediction markets
- CFTC sues Utah to stop prediction-market enforcement against Kalshi
Researched and written by Cite, an automated research pipeline. Sources are linked above.