News17 Nov 2026KalshiNew JerseySupreme CourtSports BettingCFTCState Gambling Laws
39 states and DC back New Jersey’s Supreme Court challenge to Kalshi
The state coalition wants the justices to resolve conflicting appeals-court rulings on sports prediction markets and gambling regulation.
A coalition of 39 states and the District of Columbia has urged the US Supreme Court to hear New Jersey’s challenge to prediction-market operator Kalshi, widening a dispute over whether federally regulated event contracts must also comply with state sports-gambling rules. The petition asks whether the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act stripped states of authority to regulate sports bets offered on markets registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport filed the petition on Sept. 2. As covered in September, the case seeks to settle whether Kalshi can offer sports-related contracts without complying with New Jersey’s gambling regime. The Supreme Court had not decided whether to take the case as of Nov. 16.
The challenge followed a 2-1 ruling by the Third Circuit in favor of Kalshi. The appeals court held that the company’s sports-related event contracts were swaps traded on a CFTC-licensed designated contract market, and that the Commodity Exchange Act pre-empted the applicable New Jersey laws. While that decision remains in force, it prevents New Jersey, Delaware and parts of Pennsylvania from regulating such prediction-market sports bets.
The petition points to a direct conflict with the Ninth Circuit, which concluded that bets on sporting outcomes do not fall within the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. The Sixth Circuit has also held that Kalshi’s sports contracts are not swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act and that the act does not pre-empt state regulation even if they were swaps.
Ohio, Missouri and the other states in the coalition argued that the conflicting rulings have created a national regulatory clash between federal and state authorities. New Jersey has said related litigation has spread to at least 20 states, with dozens of suits pending.
Davenport argues that platforms offering sports wagers should meet state requirements on licensing, protections for minors and problem gamblers, insider trading and consumer safeguards. “Companies like Kalshi claim to offer legal sports betting in all 50 States, but they refuse to follow the gambling laws of any State,” she said.
Kalshi has countered that it is a nationwide financial exchange that cannot be overseen by 50 separate regulators. Polymarket has similarly maintained that prediction markets belong under a federal CFTC framework rather than a patchwork of state rules. Kalshi began offering sports bets through its CFTC-registered designated contract market on Jan. 22, 2025.
The American Gaming Association, which also supports New Jersey’s petition, said state-licensed sportsbooks handled about $167 billion in wagers in 2025, generating about $16.9 billion in operator revenue and $3.7 billion in state tax revenue. Its brief said sports betting made up more than 90% of Kalshi’s trades and 95% of its revenue that year.
The case is Mary Jo Flaherty, Interim Director of the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement, et al. v. KalshiEX, LLC, docket No. 26-299.
Sources
Earlier coverage
- New Jersey asks Supreme Court to decide who regulates Kalshi sports contracts
- NFL asks Supreme Court to let states regulate sports prediction markets
- Novig asks federal court to block Wisconsin gambling case
- AGA backs New York in fight over prediction markets
- Massachusetts regulator fields prediction-market complaints it cannot resolve
Researched and written by Cite, an automated research pipeline. Sources are linked above.