Daily coverage of prediction markets.

News18 Nov 2026KalshiSports BettingCFTCSupreme Court

Fourth Circuit clears Maryland to enforce gambling laws against Kalshi

A 2-1 ruling exposed deep disagreement among the judges while adding to a circuit split over prediction markets.

A divided federal appeals court has cleared Maryland to resume pursuing Kalshi over sports-event contracts offered to customers in the state, rejecting the prediction-market operator’s bid to block state gaming enforcement.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, sitting in Richmond, Virginia, affirmed by a 2-1 vote the Maryland federal district court’s refusal to grant Kalshi a preliminary injunction. Maryland had agreed not to enforce its gambling laws while the appeal was pending, but may now bring a state-court action seeking to bar the contracts.

The case began after Maryland gaming regulators sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter demanding that it stop offering what the state called unlicensed sports wagering. The U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland first sided with the state in August 2025.

The Fourth Circuit’s majority did not rest on one rationale. Judge Roger Gregory concluded that the Commodity Exchange Act did not preempt Maryland’s gambling laws. He rejected Kalshi’s claims that the statute’s grant of exclusive jurisdiction to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission either occupied the field or conflicted with state regulation, writing that “Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so.”

Judge Stephanie Thacker reached the same result for a different reason: she concluded that Kalshi’s sports contracts are not swaps. In her reading, payment depends on the result of a completed sporting event, rather than whether an event occurs, placing the contracts outside that derivatives category.

Judge DeAndra Gist Benjamin dissented. She said the contracts qualify as swaps and that the Commodity Exchange Act therefore preempts state law. “Swaps are swaps whether they are used to gamble,” she wrote, arguing that the statute’s special rule gives the CFTC authority over gaming contracts traded on designated contract markets.

Kalshi maintains that the CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction over its sports-related event contracts, a position the agency shared during President Donald Trump’s administration. The company said the splintered ruling showed there was “no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets”; a spokesperson said the judges could not agree on why Kalshi was wrong. Jeremy Baker, acting director of the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission, said the ruling affirmed the state’s ability to regulate what he described as sports wagering.

The judgment makes the Fourth Circuit the third federal appeals court to side with a state against Kalshi. The Sixth and Ninth Circuits have also ruled against the company, while the Third Circuit held that New Jersey could not regulate it, creating a widening appellate divide over the reach of federal commodities law and state gambling rules.

As reported in September, New Jersey has already asked the Supreme Court to review the Third Circuit case over Kalshi’s sports contracts. The conflicting decisions add to the case for Supreme Court intervention, while Kalshi can also seek rehearing by the full Fourth Circuit; its response to New Jersey’s Supreme Court petition is due Dec. 7.

Sources

Earlier coverage

  1. New Jersey asks Supreme Court to decide who regulates Kalshi sports contracts
  2. Sixth Circuit lets Ohio and Tennessee enforce gambling laws against Kalshi
  3. Ninth Circuit lets Nevada enforce gambling laws against Kalshi sports contracts
  4. Kalshi sues Missouri over sports-event contract crackdown

Researched and written by Cite, an automated research pipeline. Sources are linked above.

More news

All news