Daily coverage of prediction markets.

News17 Nov 2026CFTCEvent ContractsCrypto Regulation

CFTC nominees face Senate scrutiny as prediction-market dispute deepens

Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland were set for a confirmation hearing as federal and state authority over event contracts remains contested.

Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland were scheduled to appear before the Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee on Nov. 17 for a confirmation hearing that put the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s approach to cryptocurrency and prediction markets in focus. The hearing was to be led by the committee chairman, Sen. John Boozman, with Sen. Amy Klobuchar as ranking member.

President Donald Trump sent the two nominations to the Senate on Nov. 12. Anonick, of Virginia, was nominated to succeed Rostin Behnam for a term ending June 19, 2031. Rowland, of the District of Columbia, was nominated to complete a term ending April 13, 2028, succeeding Summer K. Mersinger.

Both nominees have worked on cryptocurrency market-structure legislation, according to Legis1. Their prospective arrival would affect an agency whose remit over derivatives markets has placed it at the centre of a widening argument over event contracts, products through which traders buy and sell positions on whether specified events occur.

The core question is where federal derivatives oversight ends and state gambling regulation begins. Gambling companies and other industry groups have spent millions lobbying Congress over legislation that could influence federal oversight, while crypto companies, gambling operators and financial interests seek to shape policy.

As we reported Monday, nine Democratic senators have separately urged the CFTC to withdraw or suspend guidance on state-based access restrictions at federally regulated prediction markets, arguing that it conflicts with court orders and state and tribal gambling rules.

The CFTC’s own rulemaking record illustrates the scale of the dispute. In March, it sought public comment on the application of statutory core principles and regulations to event-contract derivatives, including contracts that could be barred as contrary to the public interest. The notice recorded 3,561 comments at Regulations.gov, and said applications to operate designated contract markets had more than doubled over the preceding year, largely from entities seeking to run prediction markets.

The agency describes such markets as information-aggregation vehicles, saying their prices reflect traders’ collective views on whether an event will happen. But it may prohibit contracts involving unlawful activity, terrorism, assassination, war, gaming or similar activity under authority implemented through Regulation 40.11.

The legal position is also unsettled. A divided Third Circuit panel held in April that the CFTC had exclusive jurisdiction over Kalshi’s sports-related event contracts and that the Commodity Exchange Act pre-empted New Jersey gambling law as applied to them. Judge Jane Roth dissented, describing the products as gambling. Courts have reached conflicting conclusions in related disputes, and prediction-market participants have brought pre-emption suits against 11 states.

The CFTC had previously proposed rules in 2024 to specify which event contracts fell under its public-interest authority, then withdrew them this year for reconsideration in light of state action and litigation. Its Division of Market Oversight also issued a March advisory addressing exchange obligations and issues with particular relevance to sports-related event contracts.

Sources

Earlier coverage

  1. CFTC moves to codify prediction-market rules as debate over manipulation intensifies
  2. Nine Democratic senators press CFTC to reverse prediction-market geofencing guidance
  3. CFTC sends duelling prediction-market definitions to White House review
  4. CFTC says prediction-market trades can trigger insider-trading liability
  5. CFTC chair denounces state criminal cases against prediction-market executives

Researched and written by Cite, an automated research pipeline. Sources are linked above.

More news

All news