News19 Nov 2026NovigLudlow ExchangeOhioSports BettingCFTCCommodity Exchange Act
Novig challenges Ohio’s sports-contract licensing regime
The prediction-market operator’s latest state lawsuit confronts a Sixth Circuit ruling that favoured Ohio’s authority to enforce gambling law.
Ludlow Exchange LLC, Novig’s federally licensed designated contract market, filed a federal lawsuit against Ohio officials on Nov. 16, contesting the state’s ability to apply gambling restrictions to its sports event contracts.
The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, names Attorney General Andy Wilson and Ohio Casino Control Commission officials Andromeda Morrison and Thomas Stickrath. Betting News reported the filing.
Ludlow argues that the Commodity Exchange Act places its federally regulated contracts within the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s exclusive jurisdiction. On that basis, it says Ohio cannot require sports-betting licences for the contracts.
The company also challenges licensing provisions that require an in-state business presence or a contractual relationship with an Ohio-based proprietor. It says those conditions create unconstitutional barriers to interstate commerce.
The suit extends Novig’s state-by-state litigation campaign. As reported in October, Ludlow sued Missouri officials after the state moved to apply its sports-wagering regime to Novig’s contracts.
Ohio’s sports-gaming system began in January 2023 and permits licensed online sportsbooks and brick-and-mortar establishments. It is generally governed by Revised Code Chapter 3775 and Ohio Administrative Code Agency 3775; state law defines sports gaming as accepting wagers on sporting events, with licensing, tax and consumer-protection requirements.
Ohio regulators maintain that sports event contracts amount to sports gambling and need state authorization. In October, the Casino Control Commission sent cease-and-desist notices to 10 prediction-market operators, warning that continued offerings could bring felony illegal-gambling and bookmaking charges, as well as fines equal to money collected from Ohio users.
Novig faces an unfavourable Sixth Circuit precedent. In KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler, decided Sept. 25, the Sixth Circuit held that Kalshi had not shown its sports-event contracts met the statutory definition of swaps under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. The court also concluded that the Commodity Exchange Act did not expressly or implicitly pre-empt Ohio and Tennessee gambling laws, affirming denial of Kalshi’s preliminary injunction in Ohio.
Ludlow contends that Schuler is not final because a rehearing request is pending before the full Sixth Circuit and three Supreme Court certiorari petitions raise the same pre-emption question. It further argues that CFTC actions on Oct. 9, including an interim final rule and a proposed rule, changed the legal landscape and support treating sports-related contracts as swaps.
That regulatory argument has already met resistance in New York. On Nov. 10, Manhattan federal Judge Colleen McMahon denied Novig a preliminary injunction, finding its contracts were sports betting rather than swaps. She considered the same CFTC materials, whose proposed rule classified sports contracts as swaps while the interim rule excluded sportsbook wagers and casino-style products, describing the agency’s positions as irreconcilable.
The appellate law remains divided. The Third Circuit held in April that Kalshi’s sports-related contracts were swaps and that federal commodities law pre-empted New Jersey gambling law as applied to them, reasoning that state oversight would obstruct the federal regime. The Ninth Circuit, like the Sixth, has held that the Commodity Exchange Act does not pre-empt state gaming regulation of sports-event contracts.
Novig has now sued officials in seven states since launching its near-nationwide platform in August: Massachusetts, Missouri, New Mexico, New York, Ohio, Washington and Wisconsin. More broadly, prediction-market participants have brought pre-emption suits involving 11 states.
The dispute has intensified after a Nov. 5 CFTC interpretation gave prediction-market platforms 30 days to stop geofencing individual states, arguing that geographic restrictions could breach federal impartial-access requirements. Nine Democratic senators questioned the agency about that directive on Nov. 16.
Sources
Earlier coverage
- Novig sues Missouri to block enforcement over sports event contracts
- Novig asks federal court to block Wisconsin gambling case
- Polymarket’s QCX sues Ohio over sports-contract licensing rules
- Novig appeals New York injunction loss to Second Circuit
- Polymarket US sues Missouri over sports event-contract crackdown
Researched and written by Cite, an automated research pipeline. Sources are linked above.